Andi Wagner

Case Information:

Andi Madison Wagner was 24 years old when she disappeared from the Evansville and Oakland City area of Indiana on August 6, 2022.

She had been making plans to turn her life around, including moving to Texas to live with her mother, Elane Garcia, and pursue sobriety after struggling with addiction.

Her family described her as a giving person who once shared her own Halloween candy with neighbors when supplies ran out. At the time of her disappearance, Andi was actively trying to rebuild her life with strong support from relatives who loved her deeply.

Case Details:

Andi was last seen leaving her grandparents’ home in Evansville before heading toward the Oakland City area, roughly 40 minutes north. She had returned home briefly to pack and was seen later that day in Oakland City, Indiana.

Her case gained attention after a tip suggested possible involvement in sex trafficking, prompting limited FBI engagement. Andi’s mother later relocated from Texas to Indiana to lead her own search efforts after facing what the family perceived as minimal official progress.

Timeline of Events:

On August 6, 2022, Andi Wagner spent a short time at her grandparents’ residence in Evansville before departing. She exchanged text messages with family that day, which proved to be her final communication.

Six days later, on August 12, 2022, her family reported her missing to the Evansville Police Department. In May 2024, authorities searched multiple properties in the Oakland City area following tips received by the FBI.

Investigation:

The Evansville Police Department leads the primary investigation into Andi’s disappearance, with occasional involvement from the FBI and Gibson County Sheriff’s Office. A $25,000 reward has been offered for information leading to her recovery or the resolution of the case.

Searches in Oakland City have yielded no definitive answers thus far. The family has expressed frustration over limited media coverage and what they view as insufficient sustained law enforcement resources.

Community Response:

Local advocates and missing persons networks have worked to keep Andi’s story visible through social media campaigns and awareness groups. The Facebook community BeAndisVoice continues to serve as a central hub for sharing updates and seeking tips from the public.

Despite the passage of time, supporters remain committed to amplifying her name across Indiana and beyond, hoping renewed attention will generate new leads.

Family Statements:

Andi’s mother, Elane Garcia, moved from Texas to Indiana in hopes of finding her daughter and bringing her home. The family has consistently emphasized Andi’s loving nature and her desire to get clean and start fresh.

They continue to plead for anyone with information to come forward, stating that Andi was deeply loved and that her absence has left an irreplaceable void.

Physical Appearance:

At the time of her disappearance, Andi Madison Wagner was 24 years old, white, approximately 5’4″ to 5′ 6″ in height, and weighed around 110–120 pounds. She had brown hair and hazel eyes, with distinctive tattoos on her forearms.

She often wore casual clothing and had a warm, approachable demeanor consistent with her compassionate personality.

Current Status:

Andi Madison Wagner remains missing, and her case is classified as endangered. No arrests have been made, and her whereabouts are still unknown more than three years later. Her family and advocates persist in their search for answers.

Contact Information:

Anyone with information about Andi Madison Wagner’s disappearance is urged to contact the Evansville Police Department or by phone at 812-436-7896.

Tips can be submitted to Gibson County Sheriff’s Office or NamUs Case: #MP94334.

---