Sara Gallagher

Case Information:

Sara Gallagher was 44 years old when she vanished under highly suspicious circumstances from Lantana, Florida, on October 23, 2024. A seasoned professional who had served in the Human Resources Department at Halifax Health for over a decade, her sudden disappearance occurred while she was out walking her nine-year-old pit bull, Cooper.

The final confirmed contact with Sara Gallagher took place on the evening of her mother’s birthday, after which her phone pings ceased and her digital footprint vanished. Despite her established career and lack of criminal history, neither Sara nor her canine companion has been seen since that autumn night.

Case Details:

At the time she went missing, Sara was known to be operating a white 2023 Kia with Florida license plate 37KPP, a vehicle that has notably never been recovered. This detail, combined with her sudden silence, has led investigators to classify her as an endangered missing person.

Sara is described as a “social butterfly” who maintained deep ties with her family in Pennsylvania, making her lack of communication around the 2024 holidays especially alarming. Her dog, Cooper, is an essential key to her identification, as he possesses distinct, identifiable masses or lumps on his back.

Timeline of Events:

On October 23, 2024, Sara Gallagher was reportedly dropped off with Cooper near The Hive, a dog-friendly establishment in Lake Worth Beach. It is believed she intended to spend the evening there before returning to the residential intersection of Hypoluxo Road and Eastview Drive.

By mid-November, the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office launched a formal investigation after she failed to respond to a wellness check. The window between her social outing and the realization of her disappearance remains the primary focus for detectives attempting to reconstruct her final movements.

Investigation:

In April 2025, a significant forensic operation was conducted on the 6000 block of Eastview Drive, led by the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office. They were assisted by the Florida Gulf Coast University Human Identity and Trauma Analysis Department, a team specializing in high-stakes forensic recovery.

While the day-long search yielded no immediate physical evidence, it signaled a shift in the investigation toward potential foul play. Authorities are continuing to analyze cellular data and potential ride-share records to determine if Sara was meeting an unknown individual on the night she vanished.

Community Response:

The disappearance of such a prominent professional has sent shockwaves through Palm Beach County, prompting a surge of community-led search efforts. Colleagues from Halifax Health and local neighbors have distributed thousands of flyers featuring the distinctive markings of her dog, Cooper.

Online advocacy groups have focused heavily on the lack of a recovered vehicle, urging residents to report any abandoned white Kias in the Lantana area. The community remains vigilant, holding onto the hope that the unique physical traits of her pet will eventually lead to a breakthrough.

Family Statements:

Joe Gallagher, Sara’s brother, has voiced the family’s growing desperation, stating that her disappearance is “highly unusual” for someone so socially active and responsible. He emphasized that Sara’s love for Cooper was so profound that she would never have abandoned him or traveled far without him.

The family is pleading for anyone who may have been at The Hive on October 23 to review their personal photos or videos for any sign of Sara or her dog. They remain steadfast in their pursuit of justice, refusing to let the case fade from the public consciousness.

Physical Appearance:

Sara Gallagher is a white female standing 5’7″ tall and weighing 120 pounds, with brown hair and brown eyes. She is further identified by a tattoo on her ankle and her characteristic professional and engaging personality.

Her dog, Cooper, is a 9-year-old brown and white pit bull who is vital to the search due to the prominent lumps on his back. Law enforcement has entered her details into the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System to assist in a nationwide search.

Current Status:

As of April 2026, the case of Sara Eileen Gallagher remains an active, unsolved endangered missing persons investigation. There have been no confirmed sightings of her or her vehicle since October 2024, and her white 2023 Kia remains on the national registry of unrecovered vehicles.

The Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office continues to categorize this as a high-priority case involving suspicious circumstances. A reward is available for information that leads to her location, as her family and law enforcement continue to seek the one lead that will bring her home.

Contact Information:

If you have any information regarding the whereabouts of Sara Gallagher or her dog, Cooper, please contact the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office at (561) 688-3000.

All tips for Sara Gallagher should reference Case Number 24-121809 or can be submitted anonymously to Crime Stoppers of Palm Beach County.

---