Shanaya Coley

Case Information:

Shanaya Coley was 24 years old when she vanished under violent circumstances from Paterson, New Jersey, on the night of December 5, 2017. A dedicated mother and nursing assistant, her sudden absence triggered an intensive multi-agency search that spanned several months.

The investigation reached a tragic turning point in May 2018, when her vehicle was located in a local apartment complex. While the search for her person concluded, the pursuit of justice remains an active and ongoing priority for the Passaic County Prosecutor’s Office.

Case Details:

Shanaya Coley was preparing for her shift at a healthcare facility when she was targeted in the parking area of her residence on Colonial Avenue. Witnesses reported a harrowing scene where an unidentified male stabbed her before forcing her into her own charcoal gray 2013 Nissan Altima.

The suspect utilized her vehicle as a getaway car, fleeing the scene and leaving behind forensic evidence that suggested a struggle of significant violence. Despite the presence of witnesses to the initial altercation, the suspect’s identity and subsequent movements remained obscured by the darkness of the late-night hour.

Timeline of Events:

The incident began at approximately 11:00 p.m. as Shanaya Coley exited her apartment to begin her nightly commute. Moments later, the violent abduction occurred, and the vehicle was observed exiting a nearby Walgreens parking lot, effectively disappearing from the view of surveillance systems.

For five months, the charcoal Nissan remained hidden in plain sight at a garden apartment complex on Marion Street, less than a mile from the abduction site. On May 6, 2018, a resident alerted the Paterson Police Department after discovering the unattended car and noticing a pervasive, foul odor.

Investigation:

Shanaya Coley’s body was discovered concealed in the backseat under a white sheet upon the recovery of the vehicle. The New Jersey Medical Examiner’s Office subsequently ruled the death a homicide, citing puncture and incision wounds as the cause of death.

Detectives have vetted numerous leads, including potential domestic motives and theories regarding the vehicle’s long-term placement in the Marion Street complex. However, the lack of definitive surveillance footage from the exact moment of the stabbing has complicated the effort to name a formal suspect.

Community Response:

The Paterson Community has demonstrated remarkable resilience, holding vigils and maintaining public awareness through the Who Murdered Shanaya Coley? advocacy group. This collective effort ensures that the details of her case—specifically the NJ plate R74-HRX—remain fresh in the minds of local residents.

Social media remains a critical tool for the family, who work alongside advocacy groups to prevent the case from growing cold. Their hope is that someone who lived in the Marion Street complex during the winter of 2017 will recall seeing an individual moving the vehicle or acting suspiciously.

Family Statements:

Willie Coley, Shanaya’s father, has been a tireless voice for his daughter, frequently addressing the media to remind the public of the son Shanaya left behind. He characterizes the scene left on Colonial Avenue as a clear indication of a forced and brutal removal that should have been solved years ago.

The family continues to challenge reports regarding Shanaya’s personal history, focusing instead on her character as a hardworking student with no known enemies. They maintain that the answer to her homicide lies within the tight-knit radius where her car was eventually recovered.

Physical Appearance:

Shanaya Coley was described as a 24-year-old Black female with a petite build at the time of her disappearance. She was last seen wearing her nursing scrubs, as she was in the process of transitioning to her workplace at the time of the attack.

Key identifiers included her glasses, which were recovered at the scene, and her 2013 Nissan Altima. While her case is no longer listed in active missing persons databases, her physical descriptions from the initial search remain a part of the public record to assist in identifying any witnesses from that night.

Current Status:

The homicide of Shanaya Coley remains an open investigation under the jurisdiction of the Passaic County Prosecutor’s Office as we enter 2026. Despite the years that have passed, law enforcement continues to seek a breakthrough that will link a suspect to the forensic evidence found within the recovered vehicle.

No arrests have been made, and no suspects have been officially identified by the Major Crimes Division. Authorities believe that a transition in loyalties or a new witness statement regarding the Marion Street complex could finally bring this investigation to a close.

Contact Information:

If you have any information regarding the homicide of Shanaya Coley, please contact the Passaic County Prosecutor’s Office tip line at 1‑877‑370‑PCPO or via email at tips@passaiccountynj.org.

Additionally, you may contact the Paterson Police Department Detective Bureau at 973‑321‑1120. Even the smallest detail regarding the charcoal Nissan Altima between December 2017 and May 2018 could be vital.

---