Gretchen Fleming

Case Information:

Gretchen Fleming, age 27, vanished from Parkersburg, West Virginia, and was last seen alive in the early morning hours of December 4, 2022.

Investigators determined that she spent the prior evening visiting multiple downtown establishments before missing her transit home, sparking an intensive multi-agency search that spanned over three years.

Her family formally reported her missing to the Parkersburg Police Department on December 12, 2022, after realizing her prolonged silence was entirely uncharacteristic for her creative and communicative nature.

Case Details:

The investigation revealed that Gretchen spent her final known hours at the My Way Lounge & Restaurant, a popular establishment located near the riverfront in downtown Parkersburg.

Law enforcement officials reviewed extensive area surveillance footage, which captured her exiting the venue around 3:00 a.m. in the company of an older male acquaintance.

When questioned by detectives early in the probe, this individual claimed that Gretchen left his vehicle voluntarily, but her personal purse, cell phone, and debit cards were later discovered abandoned, pointing to a far more ominous situation.

Timeline of Events:

• December 3, 2022: Gretchen coordinates with friends to spend the evening visiting several local venues in the Parkersburg area.
• December 4, 2022 (3:00 A.M.): She is last seen alive leaving the My Way Lounge & Restaurant with an older male acquaintance.
• December 12, 2022: Her family files an official missing persons report with local authorities after a week without contact.
• September 2025: A hunter discovers unidentified human remains hidden in a remote, wooded area of neighboring Wirt County.
• May 2026: Authorities announce a positive DNA match on the remains and execute a high-risk arrest warrant out of state.

Investigation:

The search for answers was spearheaded by the Parkersburg Police Department, with tactical assistance from regional field offices of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.

Detectives executed dozens of search warrants across multiple counties, focusing heavily on a person of interest who was seen with Gretchen on the night she disappeared.

In September 2025, the case took a somber turn when skeletal remains were discovered in rural Wirt County, prompting a meticulous forensic analysis to determine if they belonged to the missing Vienna resident.

Community Response:

The disappearance of the young writer and musician deeply shook the tight-knit Mid-Ohio Valley region, prompting immediate grassroots mobilization.

Local advocacy groups, including the Wood County Women’s Rights Alliance, organized massive candlelight vigils at Point Park to keep her name in the public eye and offer mutual support. Banners, posters, and flyers bearing her likeness remained fixtures in storefront windows across the city for years as community members refused to let her memory fade.

Family Statements:

Throughout the agonizing years of uncertainty, Gretchen’s father, David Fleming, consistently pleaded for anyone with information to break their silence and speak with law enforcement.

He expressed profound gratitude to the community for their unwavering emotional support and to the detectives who worked around the clock on her behalf. Her closest childhood friends frequently shared memories of her vibrant, artistic personality, describing her as a unique soul who left a lasting impression on everyone she met.

Physical Appearance:

Gretchen was described as a white female standing between 5’0″ and 5’2″ tall, weighing approximately 100 to 120 pounds at the time of her disappearance. She possessed straight, shoulder-length brown hair, expressive brown eyes, and a light complexion.

Known for her distinct and creative sense of style, she was right-handed and often made a memorable impression through her artistic expression and love for music.

Current Status:

In May 2026, Police Chief Matthew Board announced a monumental breakthrough in the case, confirming that the remains found in Wirt County were positively identified as Gretchen Fleming.

Concurrently, a grand jury handed down a four-count indictment against 58-year-old Preston Pierce, charging him with first-degree murder, felony murder, kidnapping, and concealment of a deceased human body.

Pierce was apprehended by the U.S. Marshals Service in Asheville, North Carolina, and is currently awaiting a formal extradition hearing to face trial in West Virginia.

Contact Information:

Although an arrest has been made, prosecutors and detectives are still actively compiling evidence to secure a conviction.

Anyone who possesses additional information regarding Preston Pierce, or who witnessed anything unusual near the My Way Lounge on December 4, 2022, is strongly urged to contact the Parkersburg Police Department’s Missing Persons Unit at (304) 424-8444 or lead Detective J.M. Zimmerman at (304) 424-1072, referencing case number P2207164.

---